William H. Brock, contributor
The historian Herbert Butterfield once dismissed writers on alchemy as being "tinctured with the kind of lunacy they set out to describe". There is no danger of that slur being cast at Lawrence Principe for his new book, The Secrets of Alchemy.
A historian of science and practising chemist, Principe provides a dazzling account of how scholarly opinion on the relationship between alchemy and chemistry has transformed in the last four decades. In the process he brings chemical knowledge and historical detective work to a subject that has too readily been dismissed as fraudulent nonsense.
The first part of his book takes us swiftly from the origins of alchemy among Graeco-Egyptian artisans, its further development among the Arabs, and then its flowering in medieval Europe as practitioners sought to prepare elixirs and medicinal compounds.
Principe then jumps to a fascinating explanation of alchemy's decline and rejection during the 18th-century Enlightenment. It was only at this point, at the pinnacle of a chemical revolution linked to the French nobleman and chemist Antoine Lavoisier, that alchemy took on the restricted meaning of turning base metals into gold; before then, alchemy and chemistry had been virtually interchangeable.
To avoid this misconception, Principe refers to chemistry prior to Lavoisier as "chymistry", underlining the fact that while its practitioners held a worldview quite different from those of modern chemists, their practical activities are not so different from those used today. He argues that the reinterpretation of alchemy as a metaphor for spiritual transmutation, by 19th and 20th-century occultists including Carl Jung, was both erroneous and unfortunate. It was this faulty reading of alchemy, Principe contends, that led uncritical historians to deny any historical continuity between chymistry and modern chemistry.
Finally, he returns to the pre-Enlightenment era, when gold-making was but one of the many activities of practical chymists. In the two striking final chapters he shows how obscure alchemical texts - with their extraordinary illustrations and multiple hidden names for common substances - can be read like cryptic puzzles.
By reproducing alchemical recipes in a modern laboratory, Principe reveals the accurate accounts of physical and chemical changes they contain. His book includes coloured plates of his intriguing results. For example, he demonstrates that well-known chymical practitioners such as Robert Boyle and Isaac Newton understood the rule of conservation of mass and framed their findings in terms of matter having a particulate structure.
The book wears its scholarship lightly and is a pleasure to read. Its fundamental message is that, although transmutation of base metals into gold was fanciful, alchemists' accounts of the real chemical changes they witnessed were far from imaginary.
Book information
The Secrets of Alchemy by Lawrence M. Principe
University of Chicago Press
?16/$25
William H. Brock has written several books on the history of chemistry, including The Case of the Poisonous Socks (Royal Society of Chemistry, 2011)
What smells with its feet and pees with its head?
Cian O'Luanaigh, contributor
In Walking Sideways, Judith Weis treads a line between popular science and biology textbook for an account of crab diversity, ecology, behaviour and anatomy, with a little on fisheries thrown in at the end. Weis celebrates crabs' many adaptations to deal with different depths, temperatures, salinity and oxygen levels both in and out of the sea.
The book is filled with fascinating facts - why crab blood is blue, for example, and why the horseshoe crab isn't a crab. She also introduces plenty of unique characters, including the Yeti crab, whose pincers are covered with hair-like filaments full of bacteria, or the coconut crab, that drowns if submerged. Then there's the Caribbean land crab, which is so averse to water it throws its eggs, which need water to hatch, off sea cliffs to avoid getting wet.
The beauty is in the weirdness. Crabs smell with their feet, which seems fortunate given they pee with their heads. Land crabs can reprocess their urine, passing it back over their gills to reabsorb salts before excreting it out a hole near their antennae. Delightfully, the scientific symbol denoting the "final excretory product" is P.
Though some passages read like lists of examples, and the prose can be clunky (repeated references to "these sideways-walking crustaceans" had me cringing), Weis definitely shares her sense of wonder, and leaves you with the impression that you have only scratched the exoskeleton.
Book Information
Walking Sideways by Judith S. Weis
Comstock/Cornell University Press
?18.50/$29.95
Follow @CultureLabNS on Twitter
Like us on Facebook
whitney houston death the vow the voice season 2 ron paul maine safe house jay z and beyonce baby cpac
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.